Sorry, Apologists: Trump’s ‘Enemy From Within’ Language Is Dangerous.

The essence of anti-anti-Trump conservatism is not to openly celebrate Donald Trump’s moral deformities but instead to deny and deflect. Trump has embarrassed the anti-anti-Trumpers by labeling his domestic opponents an “enemy from within” and calling for the military to be used against them. Marc Thiessen, an anti-anti-Trump conservative, responds to these uncomfortable developments by insisting in a Washington Post column that they never happened.

“Kamala Harris clearly has settled on a closing argument: Donald Trump is a fascist who ‘calls Americans who disagree with him the “enemy from within” and says that, as commander in chief, “he would use the military to go after them.”’ This is the desperate and dishonest strategy of a campaign that must believe it is losing,” he writes.

Thiessen begins by arguing that the first time Trump called Democrats “the enemy within” he was only referring to Adam Schiff, and this didn’t count, because Schiff has accused Trump of colluding with Russia: “When Trump used the phrase ‘enemies from within’ at a rally this month in Coachella, California, he was specifically referring to ‘shifty Adam Schiff’ — a.k.a former House Intelligence Committee chairman Adam Schiff (D-California), who is not a person who merely disagrees with Trump.”

Even putting aside the weird logic — it doesn’t count if you’re saying it about Adam Schiff — this bizarre argument isn’t even factually accurate. Trump has used the “enemy from within” construction multiple times and explicitly extended it to other Democrats.

“You call Americans who don’t support you ‘the enemy within.’ That’s a pretty ominous phrase to use about other Americans,” Howard Kurtz asked him. Trump replied, “I think that’s accurate … These are bad people. We have a lot of bad people. But when you look at shifty Schiff and some of the others, yeah, they are to me the enemy from within. I think Nancy Pelosi is an enemy from within.” 

After arguing that Trump only applied the label to Schiff, Thiessen then concedes he also applied it to other Democrats. “Trump later expanded the attack beyond Schiff, but it’s also true that Schiff was not the only Democrat pushing the lie that Trump was a Russian agent.” 

So Thiessen is saying Trump is not calling his political opponents “the enemy within,” he’s only saying this about people who question his corrupt relationship with Russia, which includes all of his political opponents? I wonder if a fact-checker brought this up late in the process, and Thiessen it was too late to revise his conclusion even though it was built upon a false premise.

Thiessen proceeds to insist, “Trump also did not say, as Harris claims, that he would use the American military to go after his political opponents.” His argument is that, in the interview in which Trump called for using the military against Americans, he was referring narrowly to Election Day. “The words ‘in terms of Election Day’ are omitted from the clip [Harris] plays, to mask the fact that Trump was answering a question about possible Election Day unrest — which he said could be ‘easily handled’ by National Guard,” insists Thiessen.

First, the fact that Trump was calling for a specific day for military violence against Democrats doesn’t really change the meaning of the answer dramatically. Second, and more importantly, Trump repeatedly demanded military force against peaceful protests during his presidency. Here are two stories (“Trump alumni warn he could deploy troops against Americans”; “Former Trump official agrees with John Kelly: Trump ‘does not operate by the rule of law’”) reporting in detail about Trump alumni who witnessed these debates firsthand. Trump’s allies are also making specific plans to use the Insurrection Act against domestic protests.

The usual anti-anti-Trump argument is to point to the fact that these abuses were prevented in Trump’s first term as a reason not to worry about them, while ignoring the fact that the people who prevented them are being blackballed from the next Trump presidency and publicly warning that he is too dangerous to be given another chance to implement his plans.

Thiessen is entitled to make this case, or to say he has some other reason to favor Trump. But I don’t see why the Post has to let him make factually untrue claims in its pages.

 

Speaking of undaunted confidence in the face of the facts, The Free Press has a column by Nellie Bowles jauntily describing the terrified warnings from Trump alumni about his plans to abuse power in general, and specifically saying he wished his generals were more like Hitler’s. “I’m gonna need one of those guys to go on the record,” she retorts skeptically, “Till then, I’m staying in this bathrobe.” 

I pointed out on Twitter that Kelly has, in fact, gone on the record. Bowles corrected her claim, which now reads, “I’m gonna need the recordings.” So the standard of proof is higher, but the overall tone of bemused skepticism remains in place.

Don’t worry, if it happens, The Free Press will spring into action with deep coverage of campus radicals.

 

Tucker Carlson, speaking at a Turning Point rally for Trump, had a riff that was creepy even by Carlson’s standards. He likened a prospective second Trump term to an angry father returning to discipline his unruly children:

There has to be a point at which Dad comes home … and he's pissed. 

Dad is pissed. He's not vengeful. He loves his children disobedient as they may be. He loves them because they're his children …

And when Dad gets home, you know what he says? 

You've been a bad girl. You've been a bad little girl, and you're getting a vigorous spanking right now. And no, it's not gonna hurt me more than it hurts you. No, it's not. I'm not gonna lie. It's gonna hurt you a lot more than it hurts me. And you earned this. You're getting a vigorous spanking because you've been a bad girl. And it has to be this way.”

The two most obvious things about this discomfiting scene are, first, it is an overtly fascist metaphor (the president as national father, forcing the public to submit to his inherently correct will out of love). Second, it is a creepy and unwanted window into Carlson’s psychosexual hangups.

But third — a less important but still relevant point I haven’t seen made — is that Carlson is describing horrible parenting.

Carlson presents his case for corporal punishment as self-evident. “If you allow it, you will encourage more of it,” he asserts. “If you allow your 2-year-old to smear the contents of his diaper on the wall of your living room, and you do nothing about it, if you allow your 14-year-old to light a joint at the breakfast table, if you allow your hormone-addled 15-year-old daughter to like, slam the door of your bedroom and give you the finger, you’re gonna get more of it.”

That’s the set-up for “there has to be a point at which Dad comes home” and delivers spankings. But presumably Dad has been parenting this way all along. And the misbehaving teenagers were once 2-year-olds.

The scene Carlson is painting is a family with an angry, physically abusive father dealing with children who act up and, by the time they reach adolescence, despise him. In Carlson’s telling of the scene, the father’s parenting style is not only necessary, but is the only imaginable way he can parent his children.

I don’t have any insight into the home Carlson was raised in, but this strikes me as a very sad confession.

 
 

ADVERTISER CONTENT

 
Learn more about Jeeng

Vanity Fair has an interesting story about a meeting of small magazines funded by Alexander Soros. Through the Open Society Foundations, Soros has “unleashed what felt like a flood of funding in the small-budget world of little magazines,” including The New York Review of Books, Dissent, The Baffler, Jewish Currents, and Lux, among other left-wing outlets. At one confab of Soros grantees, the leftists were shocked to learn Soros is also funding Compact, a red-brown journal dedicated to populist attacks on liberalism from the left and right.

The story conveys the displeasure of the leftists that their company included a social conservative, Sohrab Amari, from Compact, who describe it as “weird,” “odd,” and “gross.” It does not delve into why Soros has chosen Compact as one of his objects of support.

The reason is one I explained in a story earlier this summer. A group of progressive funders, led by the Hewlett Foundation, have poured millions of dollars into funding a movement to attack “neoliberalism.” Most of these attacks come from the left, but some also come from the right. The strategy is to create an intellectual consensus that the center-left program of the Democratic Party in the years before Trump was a failure, and needs to be replaced with something more radical.

The premises of this movement are not pro-Trump, exactly. But its argument is that Trump won in 2016 because of liberalism’s failures, rather than, say, more narrow reasons like Hillary Clinton’s personal unpopularity, James Comey’s bungling, and the peculiarity of the Electoral College. They have to turn Trump into a spokesperson for authentic and deep-rooted public discontent. Inevitably, this takes the form of a right-left alliance against liberalism.

My story argues that their critique is deeply misguided. The Obama presidency, which the anti-neoliberals dismiss as a failure, actually produced deep and lasting policy transformation across multiple fields. The Biden administration, which in many ways follows the anti-neoliberal prescription, accomplished far less. And the fact that the public remains much more critical of Biden than it ever was of Obama undercuts the whole premise that “neoliberalism” was the source of the Democrats’ political dilemma.

But the money continues to flow, so I assume the anti-neoliberal polemics will continue as well.

 

ADVERTISER CONTENT

 
Learn more about Jeeng
 
 

ENJOYED READING &C. BY JONATHAN CHAIT?

If you enjoyed reading &c. by Jonathan Chait, forward it to a friend. For more from Intelligencer, sign up for the daily newsletter or One Great Story to get a single editor-selected long read sent to you every weeknight. 

 
 
New York

follow us on facebook • twitter

unsubscribe  |  privacy notice  |  preferences


This email was sent to jbchait@gmail.com. Was this email forwarded to you? Sign up now to get this newsletter in your inbox.

View this email in your browser. 


Vox Media, LLC
1701 Rhode Island Ave NW, Washington, DC 20036
Copyright © 2026, All rights reserved

https://link.nymag.com/oc/56eb230a18ff438a128b4599m5s17.pz/4bccdbde